LOK 2026 (10) Ker. 156 | Lawyers of Kerala (LOK) Law Journal
LAWYERS OF KERALA LOK

The Premier Kerala Law Journal & Case Repository

Action completed successfully.
Reported Decision 15 October 2026
LOK 2026 (10) Ker. 156 Neutral Citation: 2026 KER 79190 Writ Petition Allowed

Sandeep Chandrasenan & Anr. v. Usha Krishnakumar & Ors.

Forum & Bench

High Court of Kerala

Harisankar V. Menon, J.

Case Registration

W.P. (C) No. 15055 of 2026

Disposed on: 15 October 2026

Originating Forum

NCLT, Kochi Bench

Ext.P1 in IA 12/2026 in CP 28/2022

For Petitioners: Adv. A. Kevin Thomas, Santhosh Mathew (Senior Advocate)
For Respondents: Advs. Harikumar G. (Gopinathan Nair), Isaac Thomas, Abraham Mathan, Yeswanth C.R., P.G. Chandapillai Abraham, Irene Babu, Jayasankar R.

Statutory Headnotes & Ratio Decidendi

Official LOK Syllabus
Constitutional Law & Jurisdiction Constitution of India, Art. 226 | Companies Act, 2013, S. 421

Maintainability of Writ Petition vs. Alternate Appellate Remedy before NCLAT:

Held: While Section 421 of the Companies Act provides an appellate remedy against NCLT orders, non-exercise of writ jurisdiction under Article 226 is a self-imposed rule of judicial restraint. The existence of an alternate statutory remedy does not operate as an absolute bar in cases involving the violation of the principles of natural justice. Relegating an aggrieved party to an alternate appellate forum in such circumstances serves no useful purpose.

Civil Procedure & Company Law CPC, Order I Rule 10 | Impleadment of Proper Parties | Fabricated Instruments

Necessary vs. Proper Party & Ground of Fabricated Share Transfer Deeds:

Held: A “proper party” is one whose presence enables the court or tribunal to completely, effectively, and properly adjudicate upon all matters and controversies, even if no direct decree or relief is claimed against them. Where respondents opposed interim relief on the ground that shares were transferred to third parties, and details of such transferees were disclosed only after court-ordered production of SH-4 forms, an impleadment application filed shortly thereafter cannot be rejected on grounds of delay or lack of direct prayers. Refusal to implead transferees who contend that their signatures were forged constitutes a denial of natural justice. Impugned NCLT order set aside.

Core Legal Issue

Whether the High Court under Article 226 should intervene against an interlocutory order of the NCLT dismissing an impleadment application under Order I Rule 10 CPC, when an alternate statutory remedy under Section 421 of the Companies Act exists, and whether transferees under allegedly forged share instruments are “proper parties” entitled to participate in company mismanagement proceedings.

NCLT’s Reasoning (Ext.P1 – Quashed)

  • No direct prayer or adjudicatory relief claimed against proposed transferees in original petition.
  • No challenge to the validity of share transfers was set out in original pleadings; no amendment was sought.
  • Impleadment was applied for in 2026 without sufficient explanation for delay since the 2022 counter-statement.

High Court’s Ruling (Menon, J.)

  • Alternative remedy is not a bar where natural justice principles are transgressed.
  • A proper party is necessary for complete adjudication, irrespective of direct prayers against them.
  • No delay occurred: original SH-4 transfer deeds were only filed by the company on 29.12.2025; impleadment was filed promptly on 21.01.2026.
  • Petitioners had locus to challenge as they were victims of alleged fraud and fabricated signatures.

Operative Conclusion

“In the result, this writ petition would stand allowed, setting aside Ext.P1 and allowing IA(C/Act)/12/KOB/2026 in CP(C/Act)/28/KOB/2022 on the files of NCLT, Kochi Bench.”

Editorial Notes & Practical Takeaways for Company Law Practitioners

Self-Restraint vs. Absolute Bar

The High Court reaffirms the landmark Whirlpool and Ghanashyam Mishra doctrine that Section 421 of the Companies Act does not oust writ jurisdiction when a subordinate tribunal’s decision violates natural justice.

Strategic Plea Consistency

Parties cannot plead that an adjudication cannot take place without third parties, and subsequently oppose the impleadment of those exact third parties once share transfer forms are produced on record.

Computation of Laches

Delay in filing an impleadment application is computed from the date the underlying documents and transferees’ particulars are formally brought on record, rather than when the preliminary plea was initially raised.