Just Rights For Children Alliance & Anr. v. S. Harish & Ors.
Case Numbers: Miscellaneous Application Nos. 2553-2554 of 2026 in Criminal Appeal Nos. 2161-2162 of 2024
Statutory Provisions Considered
- Section 15: Storage & possession of child pornography.
- Sections 19, 20 & 21: Mandatory reporting duties & penalties for failure.
- Sections 43 & 44: Wide public awareness & monitoring duties.
- POCSO Rules 2020, Rule 11: Reporting channels (SJPU, Local Police, Portal).
- Section 67B: Comprehensive code for electronic child abuse/exploitation.
- Section 79: Intermediary conditional safe harbour immunity.
- Section 67 & 67A: Transmission of obscene/sexually explicit content.
- Rule 3(1)(b) & (c): Due diligence to prevent content harmful to children.
- Rule 3(2): Timelines for grievance redressal (2 hrs, 36 hrs, 7 days).
- Rule 4(4): Proactive identification tools by Significant Intermediaries.
- Rule 4(6) & 4(1)(d): Tracking, transparency and monthly compliance audits.
LOK Official Headnotes & Ratio Decidendi
LOK Law Journal ReportI Scope of CSEAM: POCSO Act vs. IT Act Framework
POCSO Act, 2012 — Section 15 vs. IT Act, 2000 — Section 67B & IT Rules, 2021: While the penal threshold under Section 15 of the POCSO Act requires an explicit visual depiction of a child in a sexually abusive context to fasten penal liability, the provisions under Section 67B of the IT Act and the IT Rules, 2021 are broader and regulatory in nature.
“For the purposes of the IT Act and the Rules thereunder, CSEAM encompasses every form of electronic material harmful to children, including any material having the propensity or likelihood to facilitate, propagate or enable their exploitation and abuse… Intermediaries cannot shelter behind internal ‘advertising standards’ or community guidelines to ignore tools, applications, or indirect links facilitating such material.” (Paras 138-167)
II Mandatory Advanced Tech: Perceptual Hash Matching & URL Listing
Elimination of Platform Silos: Detection solely based on individual complaint mechanisms creates fatal delays. The Supreme Court highlighted that resizing or reformatting video frames circumvents traditional cryptographic hash checking. Hence, the Union of India must formulate periodically revisable Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) and guidelines directing significant social media intermediaries to uniformly adopt perceptual hashing (which captures color composition, acoustic cues, and audio-visual patterns) and URL listing (to neutralize redirect links to external monetized platforms). (Paras 25-50)
III National Hash & URL Database and Rigorous 3-Tier Verification
Creation via I4C Sahyog Portal or Standalone Repository: The Court directed the establishment of a centralized National Hash & URL Database. To prevent the erroneous inclusion of lawful free expression, every single entry must strictly undergo a 3-tier vetting pipeline:
IV Procedural Bifurcation: ‘Known Origin’ vs. ‘Unknown Origin’
The Bench established an operative distinction between two categories of CSEAM:
- CSEAM of ‘Known Origin’: Content matching an existing entry in the National Database. Obligation: Intermediaries must immediately disable and take down the content without holding internal re-determinations. Removals must be submitted to the database authority in a consolidated weekly audit report.
- CSEAM of ‘Unknown Origin’: Newly encountered material via platform due diligence or complaint. Obligation: Conduct internal due diligence, immediate hashing, prompt removal, and mandatory reporting within 2 hours to the Special Juvenile Police Unit (SJPU), local police, or cyber-crime portal under Rule 11 POCSO Rules, as well as to the National Database authority. (Paras 67-84, 198-199)
V Grievance Redressal Architecture & Standardized Reporting Format
Standardized Pro-Forma & Transparent Notice: Removal notices displayed in place of deleted content must specify whether action stemmed from internal detection or a National Database match, ensuring users know whether redress lies under Rule 3(2)/3A of the IT Rules or before the Database Authority. Intermediaries must deploy dedicated, trained CSEAM grievance officers, provide a uniform 2-step reporting button guaranteeing reporter anonymity, and submit data in a 9-point machine-readable metadata format (hashes, circulation modes, analyst digital signatures) integrated with NCRB and NDSO. (Paras 85-92, 124-127, 203)
VI Moving Beyond Section 79 IT Act: Exemplary Penalties & Profit Disgorgement
Inadequacy of Safe Harbour Revocation: Safe harbour forfeiture under Section 79 is a post-facto penal measure incapable of correcting systemic compliance inertia. The Supreme Court called upon the Union of India to enact a proactive regime of exemplary graded monetary fines calibrated to platform turnover and recurrence of violations (drawing from US REPORT Act, UK Online Safety Act, EU Digital Services Act, and Australia Online Safety Act).
Paywall Scrutiny: Any revenue derived by intermediaries from hosting, promoting, or distributing CSEAM behind subscription gates or paywalls must be mandatorily forfeited and disgorged. (Paras 223-279)
VII Article 21: Right to Internet Access vs. Blanket Age Bans
Affirmation of Digital Rights for Minors: Reaffirming Anuradha Bhasin (2020) and extending the ratio of Pragya Prasun (2025 INSC 599), the Court held that the right to access and use the internet is an intrinsic fundamental right under Article 21 read with Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution for adults and children alike. Blanket age-based bans on social media/internet access penalize victims, encourage evasive dark web migration, and fail proportionality review. Online safety must instead be fostered through proportionate architectural settings (parental guidance, default private profiles, child-modes) along with mandatory NCERT/SCERT core curriculum integration on digital safety and positive sex education. (Paras 280-315)
Comparative Global Regulatory & Penalty Regimes
The Supreme Court examined global best practices across primary jurisdictions to emphasize the urgency of moving past reactive immunity withdrawal under Section 79 of the IT Act:
| Jurisdiction | Technological / Database Architecture | Statutory Penalty Threshold |
|---|---|---|
| United States |
18 U.S.C. § 2258C(a)(2) NCMEC Industry & NGO Hash Sharing Platforms; CyberTipline. |
18 U.S.C. § 2258A(e) (REPORT Act 2024): Up to $600k – $850k for first default; $850k – $1 Million for subsequent defaults (graded by user threshold of 100M). |
| United Kingdom |
Ofcom Codes of Practice (ICU C9) IWF Image Hash List; Child Abuse Image Database (CAID); Perceptual Hashing. |
Online Safety Act, 2023 (ss. 10 & 137): Up to £18 Million or 10% of global annual revenue (whichever is greater), including daily continuing default rates. |
| European Union |
Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (DSA) Systemic risk assessments for VLOPs/VLOSEs, swift notice-and-action mechanisms. |
DSA Arts. 52, 74 & 76: Up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover; periodic penalty up to 5% of average daily turnover for continuing defaults. |
| Australia |
Online Safety Standards 2024 eSafety Commissioner centralized powers; mandatory hashing and ML deployment. |
Online Safety Act 2021 (ss. 143-147): Formal warnings or civil judicial penalties up to AU$ 49.5 Million per breach. |
| South Korea |
Telecommunications Business Act (Art. 30-6) KCSC Illegally Filmed Material Database; mandatory search restriction & upload block. |
TBA Arts. 22-6 & 104(1): Penalty surcharge up to 3% of sales for failure to block; administrative fines up to ₩50 Million for non-implementation. |
Mandatory Pro-Forma for Intermediary CSEAM Reporting
Prescribed under Paragraph 203 of the Order to enable automated ingestion by SJPU, Cyber Cells, Sahyog Portal, NCRB, and NDSO:
Perceptual Hash Identifier and/or direct and redirect URLs associated with the material.
Exact UTC/IST Date and Time of detection, triage, resolution, and disabling.
All associated metadata, captions, text prompts, tags, keywords, and promotional description.
Image, Video, GIF, redirect link, software application, manipulation tool, or live advertisement.
Public post, user story/ephemeral status, biography, closed channel, direct message, or cloud storage.
Depiction of real minor, synthetic/morphed generation, or identifiable ongoing rescue victim.
Designated as ‘Known Origin’ (matched Database ID) or ‘Unknown Origin’ (new internally generated hash).
User/victim grievance, court order, government intimation, proactive automated scan, or database match.
Reasoned assessment note by the trained Grievance Officer, along with digital electronic signatures ensuring institutional legal accountability.
Summary of Judicial Mandates & Final Directions (Para 316)
Lawyers of Kerala (LOK) Editorial Commentary
1. Constitutional Paradigm Shift: The Bench firmly settles the question left open in Anuradha Bhasin (2020) by adopting the doctrine in Pragya Prasun (2025), holding that internet access is an enforceable fundamental right under Article 21. By rejecting blanket age bans, the Court balances state paternalism against the autonomy and educational development of minors.
2. Redefining Intermediary Due Diligence: Social media giants can no longer discharge due diligence merely by deleting raw video files while permitting redirect monetized links to thrive under internal “advertising standards”. The IT Act regulatory perimeter is purposively widened to encompass software tools and enablers.
3. Litigation Impact: Criminal law practitioners representing victims or institutions should note that failure to inform SJPU/Cyber portal within 2 hours directly strips the platform of Section 79 safe harbour and attracts prosecution under Section 21 POCSO and Section 67B IT Act.